Since it was asked, here’s how we transitioned Ingrid.
First, we are big cosleepers here. Dave was initially way against it, and is now its biggest champion. Ingrid slept with us for the first 8 weeks or so, and then at 8w she started the night out in her crib, and ended up with us. We are still totally cool with that — we love the cosleeping, actually, and aren’t in a huge rush to end it, since we pretty much believe that Ingrid will spend most of her life NOT wanting to sleep between us, so we should enjoy the closeness while we can. We just aren’t CIO people, and never will be. It’s not what’s right for our family, it may be right for yours, but for us, it isn’t.
So the impetus for the big bed was both feeling like Ingrid was uncomfortable in the crib, as well as knowing we had a housefull of family coming. The last time my whole family was here, Kate slept on the aerobed under the christmas tree. With her coming to visit, and my parents thankful for a guest bed at all, but really wishing for a queen, and with Ingrid nearing the end of crib-ville, we went for it.
Ingrid’s been sleeping on a cot at daycare since january, when she moved up in rooms, so the only crib sleep she’s had in the last 4 months has been the first few hours at bedtime, and weekend naps. She goes to bed at 8, and between 8 and 10 we usually have to go up and replace a lost pacifier, or rub her back, and occasionally we have to move her to our bed before 10. Once in our bed, she settles right down, and I can walk away and leave her there, and she’s none the wiser. That’s one of the reasons we wanted to give her the full bed, and not do a toddler bed, because if I could lay down with her in HER bed and get that result, I wouldn’t have to worry about her falling out of our unusually high bed. Anyway, then by midnight, she’s in our bed — she wakes and cries, Dave fetches her, and we all sleep til about 6:30 on weekdays. It works well. She doesn’t "sleep through the night" but she doesn’t really wake up, either, it’s not like we are feeding her or reading stories at 1am, we’re just rubbing her back or reassuring her, basically.
First night of Operation Big Girl Bed (OBGB), we laid her down at 8, she went to sleep, and we didn’t hear a word til 1am. No lost paci, no yelp, nothing. The next night doesn’t count because Dave hadn’t put her down for a nap because ‘she didn’t seem tired" so everything was fucked, as it happens in those situations. The third night, she went to bed at 8, had one cry and I rubbed her back for just a minute, and then she ended up with us around 1 again. Last night?
Last night we put her in bed at 8. And she woke up at 5:55 and started talking to the pictures on her walls. No lie. I can count on one hand the number of times she’s slept through the night, and it’s never been that long. I know that sleep isn’t linear, that this doesn’t mean she will now sleep through the night forever, but her sleep has totally improved, IMO. And it’s been so great to be able to snuggle with her — on the Sunday where "she didn’t seem tired" Dave had to work at 3, and that’s about when she was crying to go to bed, so she napped for an hour and woke up crying, so I went up to her and could see she wasn’t ready to wake, so I laid down with her and we BOTH napped for another hour. It was pretty cool.
As far as the bed itself — we tried to make it as much like our bed as possible, egg crate thing underneath, pillows, blanket, etc, so it’s like the "Don’t" picture for cribs (and cribs shouldn’t have all that stuff, but she’s big enough now to handle that stuff)and it’s low, against two walls, and has a rail, so for her to get out will take some work. She’s pretty impressed though, calling it "Da Big Bed!" and all.
The transition is working well for us, but we don’t have any pressing need to transition her. If we were expecting again (and we aren’t) I can see being more concerned, but I’d probably have done this move and assumed that Dave would join Ing if she needed one of us, and I’d stay in our bed with the newborn. But then again, we are big ol’ cosleeping hippies.
Of course, my coworker had a baby in December, and before that she asked me lots of questions, and I did my usual disclaimer of "what worked for OUR family was XYZ, but it may not be right for YOUR family, and that is okay" and they were DEFINITELY not going to cosleep, no way, no how. And, like Dave, they are total converts. 🙂 When I told her today about Ing’s sleeping through the night, she was like "see? and you never did CIO, and they WILL sleep through the night!" It was kind of cool to be able to offer that ray of hope to her.
It’s all so personal though. Another person I know professionally is just ALWAYS complaining about her kid, who is the same age as mine, and it’s freaking out a pregnant mutual friend, but I explained to the pregnant person that… it’s all how YOU are. "For instance, Ingrid has never slept through the night. But I don’t bitch about it, because it doesn’t bother me, because I know she will someday." And the two people I was with were SHOCKED, because being childless, they had only ever heard people complain about the sleep issue, as the only response to "not sleeping through" is to be in a state of major angst and annoyance. For me, eh. She will. She won’t always be in our bed, she won’t always need us as much as she does now, so I want to be sure to give her all that she does need, while she’s asking for it. It’s not spoiling her, it’s meeting her needs. It works for us.
When she woke at 5:55, I wasn’t like "THANK GOD, she slept through the night!" but "Oh, she’s gaining her independence!" (Plus, WE didn’t sleep through the night — at 4am it was decided I would be the one to make sure she was still breathing.) I wasn’t happy for us, but proud of her. That probably sounds twisted to some people, but that’s how it goes here.